Just Decided Cases

DR. AUGUSTINE N. MOZIE & ORS V. CHIKE MBAMALU & 2 ORS

Legalpedia Citation: (2006) Legalpedia (SC) 99115

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Fri Jul 14, 2006

Suit Number: SC. 345/2001

CORAM



PARTIES


1. DR. AUGUSTINE N. MOZIE2. VINCENT MBAMALU3. LOUIS N. MADUKAIFE4. GABRIEL M. IGWEZE5. ANDREW OBIECHINA6. NATHAN MOZIE7. REGISTRAR OF DEEDS APPELLANTS


RESPONDENTS


AREA(S) OF LAW



SUMMARY OF FACTS

The 1st appellant, a medical practitioner, desirous of building a cottage hospital and his residential accommodation, applied for a parcel of land in Ani Owelle. He applied for unspecified number of plots and the family allocated some plots of land. Problem started when the 1st appellant cleared more than what the family allocated to him.


HELD


Dismissing the appeal (By a majority of 3 to 2), the court held the appellant is only entitled to the four plots of land allocated by the family members on the preponderance of evidence before the trail court.


ISSUES


(1) Whether family members can maintain an action in respect of family property in their personal capacity.(2)  whether the 1st appellant was allocated only four plots or an indefinite or unlimited number of plots.?


RATIONES DECIDENDI


CASES CITED


1. Abubakri V. Smith 1973 6S.C.31 2. ACB V. Emostrade (2002) 8 NWLR (Pt. 770) 5013. Adekunle V. Adewale [1983] 8 SC 984. Adelaja V. Farouk (1990) 2 NWLR (Pt. 131) 137?


STATUTES REFERRED TO


NONE


CLICK HERE TO READ FULL JUDGMENT

Esther ORIAH

Recent Posts

RENCO NIGERIA LIMITED V Q OIL & GAS SERVICES LIMITED & ANOR

Legalpedia Citation: (2025-08) Legalpedia 42685 (CA) In the Court of Appeal PORT HARCORT Mon Aug…

1 week ago

ENGINEERING ENTERPRISE OF NIGER CONTRACTOR CO. OF NIGERIA VS THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF KADUNA STATE

Legalpedia Citation: Legalpedia SC KIZW In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Thu Sep 11, 2025…

1 week ago

COMMISSONER OF POLICE, WESTERN REGION VS ALOYSIUS IGWE & 2 ORS

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-01) Legalpedia 19912 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Holden at Lagos…

1 week ago

CLEMENT AKRAN VS INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-02) Legalpedia 45350 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

1 week ago

J. A. IREM VS OBUBRA DISTRICT COUNCIL AND OTHERS

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-03) Legalpedia 03348 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

1 week ago

JOHN KHALIL KHAWAM AND CO VS K CHELLARAM AND SONS (NIGERIA)

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-03) Legalpedia 49115 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

1 week ago