CHIEF JOHN OYEGUN VS CHIEF FRANCIS ARTHUR NZERIBE

Legalpedia Citation: (2010) Legalpedia (SC) 61117

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Fri Jun 4, 2010

Suit Number: LER[2010] SC 324/2002

CORAM


 TOBI, JUSTICE ,SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL

 OGBUAGU , JUSTICE ,SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL

 FABIYI JUSTICE ,SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL


PARTIES


CHIEF JOHN OYEGUN APPELLANTS


CHIEF FRANCIS ARTHUR NZERIBE

RESPONDENTS 


AREA(S) OF LAW



SUMMARY OF FACTS

The lower court dismissed the appellant’s application for extension of time to appeal against the judgment of the lower court given 13 years ago.


HELD


Appeal dismissed.


ISSUES


The court below, found as a fact that there was inordinate delay in bringing the motion/application and that the grounds of appeal, are not substantial


RATIONES DECIDENDI


CHANCES OF APPEAL SUCCEEDING


“Where the chances of an appeal succeeding, are extremely remote (as in the instant appeal), it behoves counsel in the case, to advise his client of the, uselessness of pursuing such an appeal which patently lacks merit. See the case of K. R. Textile Allied Products Ltd. v. Henry Stephens Shipping Co. Ltd. & 2 ors. (1989) 1 NWLR (Pt. 95) 115 C. A .” Per Ogbuagu J.S.C


EXERCISE OF DISCRETION BY AN APPELLATE COURT


“An Appellate Court, can interfere with the exercise of discretion when such discretion, was not exercised judiciously and judicially. See the case of Agbomeji v. Bakare & 4 ors. (1998) 7 SCNJ. 33 @ 58. But when once it is exercised judicially and judiciously, this Court cannot interfere.” Per Ogbuagu J.S.C


CASES CITED



STATUTES REFERRED TO


NONE


CLICK HERE TO READ FULL JUDGMENT