Just Decided Cases

ALRAINE (NIG) LIMITED V M.A. ESHIETT

Legalpedia Citation: (1977-01) Legalpedia (SC) 18731

In the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Fri Jan 28, 1977

Suit Number: SC. 130/1975

CORAM


UDOMA, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

MADARIKAN, JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT

OKAY ACHIKE JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT


PARTIES


ALRAINE NIGERIA LIMITED

APPELLANTS 


M.A. ESHIETT

RESPONDENTS 


AREA(S) OF LAW


LAW OF CONTRACT-CONTRACT OF EMPLOYMENT-DISMISSAL

 


SUMMARY OF FACTS

The appellant terminated the appointment of the respondent because the respondent submitted a voucher for #120 instead of #12.0 for the payment of overtime workers in the appellants company. The respondent pleaded negligence.

 


HELD


The court held that it was an isolated instance of negligence in the five years of the respondents service so could not qualify as serious negligence to justify summary dismissals.

 


ISSUES


Whether the dismissal of the plaintiff in the circumstances revealed by the facts before the court was justified or not and what measure of damages is the plaintiff entitled

 


RATIONES DECIDENDI


UNLAWFUL TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT AND DAMAGES FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT



CASES CITED


SWISS-NIGERIA WOOD INDUSTRIES LTD V.BOGO (SC 14/70 DATED 3/7/70)

P.Z.CO. LTD V. OGEDENGBE (1972)1 ALL NLR (PT 1)202

NIGERIAN PRODUCE MARKETING BOARD V.A.O ADEWUNMI (1972) 1 ALL NLR (PT2) 433

 


STATUTES REFERRED TO


Not Available

 


CLICK HERE TO READ FULL JUDGMENT

Esther ORIAH

Recent Posts

RENCO NIGERIA LIMITED V Q OIL & GAS SERVICES LIMITED & ANOR

Legalpedia Citation: (2025-08) Legalpedia 42685 (CA) In the Court of Appeal PORT HARCORT Mon Aug…

6 days ago

ENGINEERING ENTERPRISE OF NIGER CONTRACTOR CO. OF NIGERIA VS THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF KADUNA STATE

Legalpedia Citation: Legalpedia SC KIZW In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Thu Sep 11, 2025…

6 days ago

COMMISSONER OF POLICE, WESTERN REGION VS ALOYSIUS IGWE & 2 ORS

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-01) Legalpedia 19912 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria Holden at Lagos…

6 days ago

CLEMENT AKRAN VS INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-02) Legalpedia 45350 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

6 days ago

J. A. IREM VS OBUBRA DISTRICT COUNCIL AND OTHERS

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-03) Legalpedia 03348 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

6 days ago

JOHN KHALIL KHAWAM AND CO VS K CHELLARAM AND SONS (NIGERIA)

Legalpedia Citation: (1960-03) Legalpedia 49115 (SC) In the Supreme Court of Nigeria HOLDEN AT LAGOS…

6 days ago